Thursday, October 01, 2009

Partisan feelings

My brother was in town last weekend, so we took a leaf-viewing drive up into the mountains, first walking the Boreal Life Trail at the Paul Smiths VIC, then meandering up above Lake Placid on John Brown's Road. The day was sunny and cool, and the views all one could hope for, up behind the ski jumps looking east toward the Cascade Pass. As I had never visited the John Brown Farm, I took the chance to stop in for a moment.


The bearded abolitionist of my high school civics book (in life-size bronze) greeted me by the entryway--one arm sheltering an African American child, and looking out over the many-colored hills. His eyes hold a terrible purpose; you can see in them the bloody partisan night raids of "Bleeding Kansas," the armed insurrectionist, captured and brought to trial for treason by then US Army Colonel Robert E. Lee at Harpers Ferry.

Brown inspires in me very mixed feelings. One must admire those who are willing to give their life in a cause. But the willingness to take life for a cause? That gives me pause. Particularly at a time when political temperatures are rising to a boil.

Brian Mann, in the In Box blog, has been tracking some of the hotter end of politics, noting a column this week by John L. Perry, suggesting that a military coup may be the only way to preserve the nation. And in reply to my Listening Post entry about the "American character," an old friend maintained that "As an issue, abortion is the slavery of the 21st century." Even shaving a few points off for hyperbole, when I look at the statue of John Brown, and remember the legacy of slaughter and ruin it took to resolve the issue of slavery, I have to hope my friend is wrong about that.

Labels: , ,

4 Comments:

At October 01, 2009 6:15 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Yet if that person who takes a life supposedly for a cause is someone we give a uniform with a US flag patch on it, he's called Our Hero.

 
At October 01, 2009 7:55 PM, Anonymous Joe Hall said...

I have no use for John Brown or those who glorify him. He's just another murderer to me. People who are willing to kill will find a reason to do it. Those who are not, will find a reason not to.

 
At October 02, 2009 8:31 AM, Blogger Pete Klein said...

I too have held mixed feelings about John Brown. By any standard, he was a terrorist.
I disagree with the idea behind what was posted by Anonymous on two counts.
Just because someone wears a uniform does not make them a hero. The word is too widely used today, especially since Sept. 11, 2001.
Those who serve in one of the armed services are not automatically a hero - even if they are killed or injured. In war there is just plain old bad luck - and good luck. I say that having been in the Navy.
As to someone in the armed services who kills someone, that is usually just a case of self defense.
I guess what I am saying is the word hero should be limited to unique acts of valor where someone risks their life to save a life.

 
At October 03, 2009 3:35 PM, Anonymous Norman said...

I will kick off this event on Thursday evening with a performance of JOHN BROWN: TRUMPET OF FREEDOM. -n



John Brown, Slavery, and the Legacies of Revolutionary Violence in Our Own Time:
A Conference Commemorating the 150th Anniversary of the Harpers Ferry Raid

Gilder Lehrman Center's 11th Annual

International Conference
October 29-31, 2009

Yale University
New Haven, Connecticut
Thursday, October 29, William L. Harkness Hall, Room 201 (Sudler Hall), 100 Wall Street
Friday and Saturday, October 30-31, Luce Hall Auditorium, 34 Hillhouse Avenue

Discussions of the place of violence -- its forms, its causes, its justice or injustice -- in American history often begin with John Brown and his exploits in Kansas and at Harpers Ferry, Virginia, in the 1850s. Brown's image has been appropriated by groups from the left and the right.

He is a historical as well as a legendary figure, and often the myth overshadows the reality. This conference will explore the meaning and memory of John Brown as well as the problem of violence in American culture, past and present.

The conference will open on the evening of Thursday, October 29 with a performance of John Brown: Trumpet of Freedom by actor and playwright Norman Marshall. On Friday, October 30 and Saturday, October 31, conference panels will focus on four major themes:
•John Brown: A Problem in Biography
•John Brown and the Arts
•John Brown and the Legacies of Violence
•John Brown and Abolitionism
•Concluding Roundtable: A Problem for Our Own Time


Norman Thomas Marshall, the portrayer of John Brown
wbworks.com/johnbrown

 

Post a Comment

<< Home