New In Box Etiquette: Put yourself on the map
The last week or so we've had what appear to be a lot of comments to the In Box from outside the North Country -- and frankly, from outside our extended community.
All are welcome, obviously. But to clarify and shape the discussion here, I want to encourage commenters to say where you're from.
Tupper Lake? Massena? Glens Falls? Moscow or Washington DC?
Why does it matter where you're writing from?
On big national debates -- healthcare, the environment, etc. -- we've been getting more "political Spam."
That is, comments from people from outside our region who are spraying the internet with pre-canned, pre-chewed opinions.
(We first saw a lot of his during the Murphy-Tedisco race. A bunch more popped up after last week's climate change vote...)
Some are not really participating in the discussion here; others are simply uninformed about the issues and realities that shape life here in the North Country.
A second reason for outing yourself geographically is that we're big believers in the importance of place. Frankly, we're curious to know which parts of the region are joining the In Box conversation.
Again, this doesn't disqualify anyone. And this particular bit of etiquette is optional.
But if you end your comment by saying "writing from Potsdam" or "writing from Saranac Lake" we'll know where to place you on our mental maps.
Like this:
--writing from Westport


4 Comments:
It may provide a difference in how comments are viewed. Are you 'close" to the discussion or are you viewing from a "distance"?
Writing from Hammond
Boy! Everybody is going to know who I am if I include my town in my comment.
Is it OK if I shift my location to the next little town next door?
Mike, from Greig
I believe every commenter should have to give their NAME as well as where they're from. Posting strong opinions on controversial topics anonymously is cowardice. The viciousness of the comment threads about the closed bridge in Cornwall are disgraceful and not in keeping with NCPR's community ethic. I believe this wouldn't have happened without anonymous commenting. If someone has a compelling reason to be anonymous (such as threat of economic livelihood or bodily harm) s/he should e-mail one of us directly, explaining the situation and we can post the comment without the name once anonymity has been granted. These are the rules we use in our stories - why should comments be totally different?
If I remember but for the record, Pete Klein from Indian Lake, reporter for the Hamilton County Express and author of Adirondack Hikes in Hamilton County, The Dancing Valkyrie and The Vampire Valkyrie.
Post a Comment
<< Home